November 14, 2026
Redwood vs Cedar Fencing: What Actually Holds Up in the Central Valley
Redwood vs Cedar Fencing: What Actually Holds Up in the Central Valley

For most Central Valley privacy fences, we recommend redwood: it tends to stay more stable through our dry-heat swings and is a strong choice for long, sun-exposed runs. The trade-off is price: as 2027 planning estimates, a 6-foot installed redwood fence runs about $35–$60 per linear foot, compared with $30–$50 for cedar.
Cedar is still a good fence material. It often makes more sense for smaller projects, lighter-colored wood, gates, and shaded locations. We install both, and have done so locally since 2001. Here’s how we weigh redwood vs cedar fencing for actual Central Valley conditions.
How do redwood and cedar compare?
All prices and lifespans below are estimates, not guarantees. Actual results depend on lumber grade, construction, exposure, soil, and maintenance.
| Factor | Redwood | Cedar |
|---|---|---|
| Installed cost for a 6-foot privacy fence | $35–$60 per linear foot | $30–$50 per linear foot |
| Expected Central Valley service life | About 18–25 years with sound construction and care | About 15–20 years with sound construction and care |
| Rot and insect resistance | Naturally resistant; heartwood is the stronger choice | Naturally resistant; grade and heartwood content matter |
| Stability in heat | Generally less prone to twisting and cupping | Lighter, softer fiber; may move more in exposed conditions |
| Checking (surface cracks) | Can check, especially if left unfinished; typically less prone | Can check more readily in prolonged sun and dry heat |
| Color and grain | Warm red-to-brown tones; grain and color can vary | Usually lighter, more even color with a tighter-looking grain |
| Maintenance interval | Plan to inspect and refinish about every 2–3 years | Plan to inspect and refinish about every 2–3 years |
| Staining behavior | Takes stain well; natural color variations can show through | Often takes stain evenly; lighter wood can show the chosen color clearly |
| Weight and workability | Denser and heavier; still workable with proper fasteners | Lighter and easier to handle, useful for gates and small sections |
The lifespan ranges are planning estimates, not a promise that one species will always outlast the other. On a well-built fence, the posts, grade, exposure, and finish schedule can matter as much as the species.
How do redwood and cedar hold up in Central Valley weather?
Our fences face 100°F-plus summer days, strong UV, low humidity, dry winters, and, in many neighborhoods, Delta winds. Sun and dry air draw moisture from boards; seasonal moisture changes then make wood expand and contract. Both species weather and gray if left unfinished.
Redwood’s natural tannins and denser, tighter cell structure give it an edge on long, exposed fence lines. In our experience, it is less likely than cedar to twist or cup through repeated heat and drying cycles. Cedar’s lighter, more porous fiber makes it easier to handle, but full-sun exposure can be harder on its boards over time.
Both woods can develop surface checking: small cracks that form as the board dries. Cedar is generally more prone to visible checking on hot, sun-blasted runs, but redwood is not immune. On tear-outs after 15–20 years, we look at the whole structure. Boards may be faded, checked, or loose; posts and lower sections can show wear from soil contact, irrigation, or poor drainage. A finish and sound construction help, but neither species is maintenance-free.
A solid privacy fence catches wind. Redwood’s density does not replace proper construction: post size and spacing, footing depth, connections, and site conditions all matter. Fasteners can loosen as boards move, so use corrosion-resistant hardware and install it correctly.

What does the price difference mean on a 120-foot fence?
For a standard 6-foot privacy fence, use these 2027 planning estimates:
- Cedar: $30–$50 per linear foot, or about $3,600–$6,000 for 120 feet.
- Redwood: $35–$60 per linear foot, or about $4,200–$7,200 for 120 feet.
That’s a broad estimated difference of roughly $600–$1,200 when comparing the low ends with the low ends or high ends with the high ends. Gates, removal, grade, access, and fence style can change the total. For more local pricing context, see our wood fence cost guide for Modesto and 2027 Central Valley replacement cost guide.
Cost per year of service life is one useful way to compare species, as long as you treat it as a rough estimate. Using the middle of each price range and the middle of each lifespan range, cedar works out to about $2.29 per linear foot per service year ($40 ÷ 17.5 years); redwood is about $2.21 ($47.50 ÷ 21.5 years). This simple calculation excludes maintenance and assumes those estimated lifespans. It illustrates why the redwood premium may make sense for a long-term fence, but it is not a guarantee of lower lifetime cost.
How often should you stain or seal either wood?
In this climate, plan to inspect the finish and expect to stain or seal either species about every 2–3 years. A fence that gets full afternoon sun may need attention sooner than a shaded one. Follow the finish manufacturer’s directions and check how the wood is responding rather than relying on the calendar alone.
Cedar’s lighter, more even surface often shows stain color consistently. Redwood also takes stain well, though natural color variation can make the finish look less uniform from board to board. Both species turn gray when left untreated as UV exposure weathers the wood.
Here’s the important trade-off: an unstained redwood fence can degrade faster than a stained cedar fence. The maintenance schedule can matter more than a small difference between species. See our fence staining information for Modesto for local preparation and finish guidance.
Does board-on-board construction change which species to choose?
Yes. Board-on-board fences use overlapping boards, so they require more lumber than a side-by-side privacy fence. That makes the redwood price premium add up across a long run.
For board-on-board, we’d choose redwood if the budget allows, especially for a long, exposed boundary fence. Choose cedar if the run is lengthy and controlling the upfront price matters more. Either way, compare complete estimates that specify the design, lumber grade, posts, and gates.
Which species would we choose for each kind of job?
- Long, full-sun privacy fence: Redwood. Its stability makes it our recommendation for a 100-foot-plus run intended to serve for 20 years or more.
- Gate or short run: Cedar is fine and often smarter. It costs less, weighs less, and a gate may need replacement sooner than the full fence.
- Board-on-board: Redwood if the budget allows; cedar if the added lumber and overall price are the priority.
- Shaded or north-facing fence: Cedar is a reasonable choice because reduced sun exposure puts less stress on the boards.
- Light, even wood appearance: Cedar is often the better fit if that look is what you want.
What would we avoid when choosing a fence?
We would not put cedar on a long, west-facing run and expect 20 years without diligent finishing. We would not buy redwood based on the species name alone without checking grade and what the estimate includes. And we would not skip the finish schedule on either wood if the goal is to slow fading and weathering.
Does grade and installation matter as much as species?
They matter a great deal. Ask whether the boards are heartwood or contain sapwood, what grade is being installed, and what fasteners will be used. Heartwood is generally the better choice for natural decay resistance; a species label by itself does not tell you the full material quality.
Posts and footings deserve equal attention, especially where the fence catches wind or the soil holds moisture. Stainless or hot-dipped galvanized fasteners help resist corrosion. A cheap redwood fence installed badly can be a worse choice than premium cedar installed well, and vice versa.
Redwood vs cedar fence: frequently asked questions
Is redwood or cedar better for a fence?
For most long, full-sun Central Valley privacy fences, we recommend redwood for its stability in dry heat. Cedar is a strong choice for smaller, shaded, or budget-sensitive projects.
Is cedar cheaper than redwood?
Usually. As 2027 planning estimates, a 6-foot installed cedar privacy fence runs about $30–$50 per linear foot, compared with $35–$60 for redwood.
How long does a redwood fence last in the Central Valley? What about cedar?
As estimates, allow about 18–25 years for redwood and 15–20 years for cedar with suitable construction and maintenance. Exposure, grade, posts, and finishing can change the result; these are not guaranteed lifespans.
Which is better for staining?
Both take stain. Cedar’s lighter, more even appearance often shows color more consistently, while redwood’s natural variations may remain visible through a penetrating stain.
Does cedar warp more than redwood?
In our experience, cedar is more prone to movement on exposed, sun-blasted runs. Proper installation and finishing help both species, and neither is immune to warping or checking.
Which is better in high wind?
Neither species compensates for undersized posts or shallow footings. For a solid fence in a windy area, construction details and secure fasteners matter more than choosing cedar or redwood.
When is the cheaper species genuinely the right choice?
Cedar is the right answer when the fence is short, shaded, part of a rental property, or likely to be replaced before a 20-year service life matters. Spending extra for redwood can be a waste if the project is temporary or you expect to move soon. For a long, exposed fence you plan to keep, the added upfront cost of redwood may be worth considering.
What should you know about California Crews?
California Crews is family-owned and has served the Central Valley since 2001. We bring 25+ years of experience, hold contractor license #909718, carry $2M in coverage, and have 4.8 stars from 40+ reviews. Fence installations include a 5-year workmanship warranty. No deposit is required on projects of $5,000 or less, and typical project turnarounds are 3–5 days.
We serve Modesto, Manteca, Turlock, Ripon, Ceres, Oakdale, Riverbank, Salida, Waterford, and Escalon. Learn more about our wood fencing services.
For a free estimate, request one online. Most quotes are delivered within 24 hours.
About this article
Written by Penny, professional blog writer at California Crews, drawing on the straight-from-the-job experience of Joel Leer, the company's owner. Joel has built, repaired and stained fences and painted homes across California's Central Valley since 2001, and every guide on this blog comes from our own job sites in Modesto, Manteca, Turlock, Ripon, Ceres, Oakdale, Riverbank, Salida, Waterford and Escalon: the materials we install, the failures we get called back to fix, and the numbers we quote.
